Alumina Partners of Jamaica v National Workers Union


Industrial Disputes Tribunal

Lynch, C.

48 of 1977

Alumina Partners of Jamaica
National Workers Union

Labour law - Termination of employment — Dismissal.


The Honourable Minister of Labour, by letter dated 2nd November, 1977 and in accordance with section 11 of: the Labour Relations and Industrial Disputes Act, referred to the Industrial

‘Disputes Tribunal for settlement the dispute between Alumina Partners of Jamaica and the National Workers Union.


The terms of reference to the tribunal were as follows:

“To determine and settle the dispute between Alumina Partners of Jamaica on the one hand and the National Workers Union on the other hand over the dismissal of Mr. Malachi Atkinson.”


The division of the tribunal selected in accordance with section 8(2) of the Act was:

Mr. Basil Lynch — Chairman

Mr. Owen Plant — Employers' Representative

Mr. Dorrel White — Workers' Representative


The company was represented by:

Mr. P. H. Williams Q.C. (Legal)

Mr. P. Bynoe

Mr. O. Simpson


The union was represented by:

Mr. D. Buchanan — Organizer

Mr. H. Nelson — Chief Delegate

Mr. D. Panton

Mr. C. Lewis

Mr. L. Rochester


Written briefs were submitted by the parties and oral submissions made at three (3) siftings held on the 9th March, 3rd April and 13th April, 1978.


The dispute arose out of an altercation between Mr. Randolph Chin, Supervisor employed to Alpart at Port Kaiser and Mr. Malachi Atkinson also employed at Alpart at Port Raiser which resulted in the dismissal of Mr. Atkinson with effect from 24th March, 1977.


The company, through its representatives, clamed that –

“On the 10th March, 1977, Mr. Malachi Atkinson unlawfully assaulted his supervisor, Mr. Randolph Chin. As a result of this assault and in accordance with the provisions of the collective labour agreement between the parties, Mr. Atkinson was dismissed.”


The Union, through its representatives, submitted that –

“The facts are that supervisor Chin, by his denial to...

To continue reading